Each year, research firms such as CB Insights analyze why both startups and new products from mature companies fail. On average, about 80 percent of VC-backed startups fail (and those are the best of the startup world), and somewhere between 40 and 60 percent of new products launched by mature companies also fail. Invariably, the primary reason for failure is “no market need.”
Take, for example, Gap’s “faded” jeans, launched in the early 2000s to tap into the trend toward casual, relaxed denim. Despite some initial interest, the product struggled and ultimately failed to gain lasting traction.
In contrast, Abercrombie & Fitch released its “A&F jeans” during the same period. Thanks to strong marketing and their association with a trendy lifestyle, A&F jeans quickly became highly popular among young consumers and turned into a wardrobe staple throughout the early 2000s.
The empirical evidence shows that great product engineering, the emphasis of most new companies and product designers, is merely table stakes. Instead, the empirical evidence shows that it’s almost always great Market Engineering that determines winners. Unfortunately, I have discovered that few teams possess the internal skills, experience, or even the knowledge that they must engineer a market for their product or service.
This article is part of Branding Strategy Insider’s FREE newsletter. Join the world’s smartest marketers and subscribe here for actionable insights delivered directly to your inbox.
Market Engineering is the intentional design and orchestration of a company’s place in the world—not just through great product development, but through building the frameworks of belief, awareness, and demand. That is what determines whether you win the market or become just another footnote. It’s not a slogan.
Market Engineering is the discipline of architecting how a problem is understood, how your solution is interpreted, and how your company is positioned for durable success.
Within this discipline live five foundational tenets—each one essential, and together forming the “architecture of inevitability” for industry leaders:
The Five Tenets of Market Engineering
- Category Design/Redesign: Category design is not just about inventing something new; it’s about naming and defining a space so that you are seen as its obvious pioneer, even if you didn’t invent every underlying technology. It’s the act of planting your flag and shaping the market’s mental map:
- What problem matters.
- Why it matters now.
- And why your definition should be the default. Redesign is equally critical: reframing stale categories, moving the goalposts, and refusing to let competitors dictate the narrative. If you control the category, you control the terrain and the terms of competition.
- Positioning: At its core, positioning is how you anchor your company relative to competitors, alternatives, and, most importantly, the status quo. Strong positioning claims clear territory: “For whom, against whom, and why now?” It answers, “Why pick us? Why change now? Why not stay with the old solution?” In crowded, ambiguous markets, precise positioning avoids death by comparison and leverages every resource—from capital to customer credibility—for maximum effect.
- Messaging: Messaging is where strategy meets language. It’s the art and science of expressing your value proposition, positioning, and differentiation with clarity and repeatability. Effective messaging is encapsulated in a living document—a Messaging Matrix—that acts as the “source of truth” for every blog, sales call, tweet, and presentation. Get messaging right, and your product and organization can scale with clarity. Get it wrong, and every customer touchpoint dissolves into noise.
- Storytelling: Storytelling is the oxygen of Market Engineering. Humans are wired for narratives. Stories shape how we interpret risk, hope, and urgency. For startups, as well as new product launches from mature enterprises, storytelling is how products become movements, how users become evangelists, and how investors bet on teams doing the impossible. A powerful story makes otherwise rational actors feel; driving action, advocacy, and word-of-mouth in ways no product datasheet ever can. The best market engineers distill their entire value and future promise into a memorable, repeatable story.
- Thought Leadership: Thought leadership elevates your company or founder from participant to shaper—from reactionary to agenda-setter. This isn’t public relations puffery. Done right, thought leadership changes how peers, analysts, journalists, and even competitors interpret the future of your market. True thought leaders influence language, metrics, investment, and regulation. When people look to you for the “why” (not just the “what”), your company becomes the primary reference point, the “source code” for your industry’s next chapter.
Brand should strengthen competitive position, pricing power, and enterprise value. The Blake Project helps make that happen.
Integrating the Five Tenets of Market Engineering
Here’s an easy way to think about the role that each tenet of Market Engineering plays, as well as how they integrate:
- Category Design sets the playing field in which you compete.
- Positioning marks the location of your product or company on the field.
- Messaging is the day-to-day currency by which the position is evangelized.
- Storytelling explains the journey—why your position matters and how it will transform the customer.
- Thought Leadership provides the provocative, future-oriented worldview that establishes you as the leader in your category.
Why these tenets matter: As noted, product engineering is table stakes—it’s what it takes just to join the game. Market Engineering is what really determines winners. Each of these tenets reinforces the others, creating a system that shapes, and reshapes, the world’s perception and the company’s destiny. The companies that master these disciplines are not simply built to last; they are built to lead.
Contributed to Branding Strategy Insider by Bruce Cleveland, Excerpted from Market Engineering. Reprinted by permission of Silicon Valley Press. Copyright 2026 Bruce Cleveland. All rights reserved.
At The Blake Project, we help leaders turn brand into a disciplined driver of financial performance — strengthening pricing power, competitive position, and enterprise value. Email us to start a conversation about enduring profitable growth. For The EBITDA.
Branding Strategy Insider is a service of The Blake Project, a strategic brand consultancy focused on turning brand into pricing power, growth, and enterprise value.
